|David Toscano (D) incumbent||2,589||57.55|
|J. Blake Caravati (D)||2,345||52.13|
|Michael Crafaik (R)||1,679||37.32|
|James King (I)||1,539||34.21|
Voters could cast two votes, one for each of the two seats available, hence the percentages do not total 100%. 
"Let's not put in the hands of three council members a decision so crucially important to many thousands," Crafaik said.